Nanaiky ny handrarana minaret vaovao [tilikambon'ny moske silamo] tamin'ny alalan'ny fitsapa-kevi-bahoaka ny alahady 29 Novambra lasa teo ny 57,5%-n'ny mpifidy Soisa, izay manori-dalana ho amin'ny fanitsiana ny Lalampanorenana. Any amin'ny fananganana tilikambo silamo vaovao – fa tsy ny moske – moa no iantefan'ity fitsapa-kevi-bahoaka ity fa tsy any amin'ny tilikambo silamo efatra efa mijoro ao Soisa ao.
Niteraka fanehoan-kevitra isan-karazany teo amin'ny tontolom-bolongana arabo sy miozolomana moa ity fandrarana ity: Raha nitroatra ny mpamaham-bolongana sasany, ny hafa kosa manamarika fa tsy manakana ny fanaraham-pivavahana tsy akory ny fandrarana ny fananganana minaret.
Namoaka lahatsoratra manameloka ny fanapahan-kevitry ny Soisa ao amin'ity fehezan-kevitra ity ilay Libano-Amerikana Pierre Tristram mamaham-bolongana ho an'ny About.com:
How can 59 million people be so dumb, Britain's Daily Mail famously asked in a day-after headline of the re-election of George W. Bush in 2004. The Daily Mail can notch a new one for its shame gallery: How can 3 million Swiss be so bigoted?
Ary dia nofaranan'i Tristram tahaka izao ny heviny: “Nihafoana haingana dia haingana ny fahasamihafana eo amin'ny ankapoben'olona any Soisa sy ny kabarim-panavakavahana fanaon'ilay Iraniana antsoina hoe Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.”
Nikaroka ny anton'izao safidy izao ilay mpamaham-bolongana Ejipsiana Hicham Maged , ka nafehiny fa:
In a nutshell, I am looking forward for Swiss people to re-evaluate what happened; it is not only whether law protect citizen's rights or not, which is something important to debate and go for in the Swiss courts to correct for sure, but what is more important for me is that this fatal mistake should set up an alarm for not falling into the swamp of ignorance where nothing fill it but fear, anger and stupidity ~ Everywhere!
Mpamaham-bolongana Ejipsiana hafa izay manana ny anaran'ny bolongana manao hoe Not Green Data dia manaiky fa “ny moske dia moske,” saingy malahelo izy fa manimba ny hakanton'ny moske ny fandrarana ataon'ny Soisa:
Can you imagine a cube of Swiss Cheese, without its eyes – the holes in it? Or a Swiss Knife without the compass or the screwdriver? This is exactly what the Swiss people want to do with mosques. A mosque will remain a mosques without its Minarets, and it will still function the way it is supposed to function without them. But it will then loose its architectural identity and beauty.
Nifantoka tamin'ny endrik'afisy isan-karazany nataon'ny mpikatroka avy amin'ny andaniny sy ny ankilany tamin'ny fampielezan-kevitra kosa i Matthew Teller mpamaham-bolongana anglisy, mpanoratra momba ny fizahantany any Azia andrefana [Proche Orient hoy ny tandrefana]
Afisin'ny antoko Soisa SVP miantso ho amin'ny fandrarana ny minaretka mamelabelatra ity afisy hitantsika ity:
The repulsive SVP, who’ve used what the Financial Times called “strident populism” to target ‘foreigners’ of all kinds in Switzerland as criminals, benefit cheats or worse, kicked off the campaign with the poster opposite: “Stop! Yes to the minaret ban”. Look at the imagery: minarets as missiles, women as menacing, the burqa as concealment, black as a threat, the Swiss flag cast into shadow from the east, the cross obliterated.
Ilay Alzeriana-Amerikana The Moor Next Door kosa indray dia mahita ny fandrarana ho adim-pahefana ka manamarika fa:
The minaret, for its opponents, symbolizes Islam’s “arrival” in the Alps. It stands to proclaim the Muslim presence above other faiths and peoples. Banning it, then, is to ban a symbol of Muslim power and existence
…
The aesthetics of identity, and therefore power, are what the drive is really about. It is a way for a people in doubt to affirm and define their confused identity by rejecting that of the newcomer’s.
…
Ny hakanton'ny fiavahana, ny heriny, izay no tena ao ambadik'ity raharaha ity. Izao no lalana hitan'ny olona tsy tena mahalala ny maha-izy azy ka mitsipaka ny maha-izy azy an'ireo hafa tonga taty aoriana.
Manana fomba fijery miavaka amin'izay zava-dehibe indrindra amin'ity raharaha ity ilay mpamaham-bolongana Syriana Maysaloon. Raha tsy resahina ny tsy fandefera-tsaina, tahotra, ary ny dikan'ny maritrano, dia manome hevitra tahaka izao ny mpamaham-bolongana:
Neither Swiss bigotry, nor the religious or architectural significance of minarets are what is important about this story. What is important is that for the first time in 400 years, at least since the Ottomans besieged Vienna, Muslims are having a real impact on what is happening in Europe.
Ary dia nasongadin'ny mpamaham-bolongana amin'izay ny fomba nitarihan'ny Islam ny “tandrefana” sy ny mifamadika amin'izay ka nanaovany tsoa-kevitra fa:
To sum it up, I am not worried about the bigots. Minarets and sharia can be banned, headscarves can be torn off, and all the cartoons in the world will not stop the fact that Islam is now in Europe, and it is in America, and it is spreading throughout the world.
Hamaranana azy ny hevitr'ilay maoritaniana mpampiasa Twitter weddady rehefa nivoaka ny valin'ny fitsapa-kevi-bahoaka sady mamehy ny fahatsapan'ny maro. Hoy izy, ” Tsy misy afa-mandà intsony amin'izao ka hanao hoe tsy manana olana amin'ny miozolomana i Eoropa, ary tsy misy afa-mandà ny fitomboan'isan'ny miozolomana any.”
Jillian C. York
